42880 pts ยท May 1, 2013
So this is a public text thingy? Neat! My inbox is always open to artists, if you have anything you want me to take a look at, don't hesitate and throw it my way!
Just to clear up so that there's no undue drama, @corrodias agrees that your art isn't AI! :)The one claiming your art is AI was @Ciemnosc!
Yeah, i've been watching the ai slop scene evolve since the start, and @huleeb's images do not register as AI slop to me. They are abstract and sometimes strange, but i do see signs of reused 3D assets and stuff like that, which is to be expected from actual human-made work.
This is what it boils down to for you, not the facts. I haven't really said anything to defend AI, but i have been questioning your authority, and that bothers you. On top of that you're dismissing a 5+ year body of work using methods and assertions that can't really find their footing in reality. Please actually engage with what i'm writing.
Very accurate statement, for once.
You, being as in the know as you claim to be, would know that early AI couldn't even begin to approach the complexity and consistence of the images on show here. The first examples could barely make a consistent image, let alone a consistent artstyle.
Right, but imgur (as far as i know) don't let you back-post things. I've been here (silently or not) for MANY years at this point, so i have a long history to draw this assertion from. Their posts from 2020 in this case will be genuine. If you want to have a look for yourself you can go to their user profile and sort their posts by oldest.
Absolutely, that's the best guess hunt i mentioned. It may or may not be accurate. The most famous example of this is on the text side of things where the declaration of independence was declared as AI generated by a multitude of tools. You seem fairly irate and unhappy to have your assertions questioned, but i recommend you spend more than 3 minutes before you start throwing accusations like that around. What is your take on the fact that the (public) work of this user goes back 5+ years?
Of all the things i said, that's the only one you decided to take for a ride. Many AI detection websites simply look for metadata, which imgur scrubs when an image is uploaded. After that it's a best guess hunt for certain patterns which may, or may not, be accurate. Using AI for postprocessing is my guess in this case, but it's certainly not the entire story. Would you like to comment on the rest of my critique of your critique as well, or will you go silent after this?
Right, but this user has been outputting images at this rate, on this website, since 2020. It's possible that one of their postprocessing steps utilize AI, maybe even the ones you mention, but we can't know that. It's fairly disingenuous to dismiss a body of work spanning half of your own claimed time working with blender over 3 minutes of research using notoriously unreliable AI detection websites.
I'm very curious of what analysis you did in 3 minutes?
Yes.
They're in some ways worse for allergic people. Allergy causing compounds collect on their skin, but they don't shed which helps a little.
They're pretty bad for allergies unless you bathe them regularly. Most people are allergic to cat saliva and that collects on their skin.
They're not really any more clumsy than your average cat.
Sorry for your loss. We only got a month with our 14yo after diagnosis. Letting them go is the right thing.
Like butter?
Goblin layer
Not at all, they can be worse to allergic people than normal cats. What they don't do is leave hair everywhere which CAN help some.
Nope.
I can also add a recommendation for Scishow and their channel Scishow Space. Always interesting topics.
Beirut, Lebanon
This was because they licked it off their paws after walking in it. They're small so the amount needed to kill them was small as well.
As someone with two of them, no. They do not leave pucker marks.
Hey! I'm fairly sure i've seen a similar Knight to yours in a display case at a local store. Where are you based, if i might ask?
#5 Skylight.
People come up with a lot of bullshit about them because they dislike the way they look. Incredibly childish.
Uh, no, they don't smell. Source: I have two.
Nice job! Looks beaten to hell as it should!
Just to clear up so that there's no undue drama, @corrodias agrees that your art isn't AI! :)The one claiming your art is AI was @Ciemnosc!
Yeah, i've been watching the ai slop scene evolve since the start, and @huleeb's images do not register as AI slop to me. They are abstract and sometimes strange, but i do see signs of reused 3D assets and stuff like that, which is to be expected from actual human-made work.
This is what it boils down to for you, not the facts. I haven't really said anything to defend AI, but i have been questioning your authority, and that bothers you. On top of that you're dismissing a 5+ year body of work using methods and assertions that can't really find their footing in reality. Please actually engage with what i'm writing.
Very accurate statement, for once.
You, being as in the know as you claim to be, would know that early AI couldn't even begin to approach the complexity and consistence of the images on show here. The first examples could barely make a consistent image, let alone a consistent artstyle.
Right, but imgur (as far as i know) don't let you back-post things. I've been here (silently or not) for MANY years at this point, so i have a long history to draw this assertion from. Their posts from 2020 in this case will be genuine. If you want to have a look for yourself you can go to their user profile and sort their posts by oldest.
Absolutely, that's the best guess hunt i mentioned. It may or may not be accurate. The most famous example of this is on the text side of things where the declaration of independence was declared as AI generated by a multitude of tools. You seem fairly irate and unhappy to have your assertions questioned, but i recommend you spend more than 3 minutes before you start throwing accusations like that around. What is your take on the fact that the (public) work of this user goes back 5+ years?
Of all the things i said, that's the only one you decided to take for a ride. Many AI detection websites simply look for metadata, which imgur scrubs when an image is uploaded. After that it's a best guess hunt for certain patterns which may, or may not, be accurate. Using AI for postprocessing is my guess in this case, but it's certainly not the entire story. Would you like to comment on the rest of my critique of your critique as well, or will you go silent after this?
Right, but this user has been outputting images at this rate, on this website, since 2020. It's possible that one of their postprocessing steps utilize AI, maybe even the ones you mention, but we can't know that. It's fairly disingenuous to dismiss a body of work spanning half of your own claimed time working with blender over 3 minutes of research using notoriously unreliable AI detection websites.
I'm very curious of what analysis you did in 3 minutes?
Yes.
They're in some ways worse for allergic people. Allergy causing compounds collect on their skin, but they don't shed which helps a little.
They're pretty bad for allergies unless you bathe them regularly. Most people are allergic to cat saliva and that collects on their skin.
They're not really any more clumsy than your average cat.
Sorry for your loss. We only got a month with our 14yo after diagnosis. Letting them go is the right thing.
Like butter?
Goblin layer
Not at all, they can be worse to allergic people than normal cats. What they don't do is leave hair everywhere which CAN help some.
Nope.
I can also add a recommendation for Scishow and their channel Scishow Space. Always interesting topics.
Beirut, Lebanon
This was because they licked it off their paws after walking in it. They're small so the amount needed to kill them was small as well.
As someone with two of them, no. They do not leave pucker marks.
Hey! I'm fairly sure i've seen a similar Knight to yours in a display case at a local store. Where are you based, if i might ask?
#5 Skylight.
People come up with a lot of bullshit about them because they dislike the way they look. Incredibly childish.
Uh, no, they don't smell. Source: I have two.
Nice job! Looks beaten to hell as it should!