ThatPAMTHorseGal
92119
2359
61
All of these wonderful creations have been made by others.
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
I am still crying and I finished the game, like, months ago.
Cat Tax
Miyamotofan
#20 this is because they were boys for the first one and grew into men by the second one
wylkyn
I cried when my (Arthur's) horse got shot out from under me. We had been through so much. It was an amazing moment. I'm still wrecked.
EvilMadMonk
thekeyofe
#15 "Tacitus Kilgore."
OnFleekDicPics
It took me months to finish cause I couldn't stop crying
SkogensKung
John Marston is much more badass and likeable in my eyes. Just my personal opinion though.
QuidditchQueen713
Fhaegar
Thanks, partner
peepeeinthebumhole
+1 for Arthur’s twitter handle being Tacitus Kilgore
Krampus95360
AndreaFarmer9
Why must you hurt me like this? I had never outright sobbed while gaming until RDR2 came along.
Kats8652
#8 Fallout 76 and Black ops 4? Damn wouldn't be caught dead walking next to that.
bartset
Love the game, memes bring back good memories
thekeyofe
#1 I'm only in Chapter 3 right now, but I still have like $3000 in cash after purchasing all weapons and camp upgrades, so yeah.
Arcticstorm141
This game was so good, but man did it mess me up
ThatPAMTHorseGal
Same here. I still can’t listen to the soundtrack without breaking down.
Zephronias
Let me murder Micah, that's all I want. Let me leave him in that cell and watch his hanging the next day.
swedeonamoose
still sooo salty about the lack of content added for story line endgame, so much could have been adde but nope, everything go to rdr online
fragglestckcar
I would cut off a finger for a Sadie Adler DLC.
swedeonamoose
hell just the quests and stuff from online would be worth alot, fuck i'd settle for buildable hunting/fishing cabins to set up as ft spots
LoTRFanatic42
Literally watching the credits for RDR2 right now. One of the greatest games ever made. Godspeed Arthur, you beautiful bastard.
NepLeet
Oh My Lovely - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ovgGY_7Mlo
idontliketheclonebone
ThatPAMTHorseGal
Oh my gosh, that’s awesome. I haven’t seen this one.
Obetrix
One of my favorite games ever! The platinum was brutal too get though ?
curtan309
I wouldn't have put Spider-Man on that list
legnouaa
I would have paid to play Saddie....
DatDarthCaedus
RDR3 playing as Bounty Hunter Sadie or we riot. There are several years of timeskip that it could be set in.
FaustsAccountant
How about as Jake then we switch to Sadie or a yet-to-be-known character that meets young Sadie? That gives more room to create better story
jaffa5
hey who knows maybe we will in RDR 3. although i like the idea of playing as a young Dutch or Hosea during the early days of the gang.
FaustsAccountant
Sadies doesn’t need “Redemption” but how about we play as Jake or a yet-to-be-known character that meets young Sadie?
XVUltima
I sort of suspected a young Hosea would be a protag in a prequel game. The way some of his lines are written...it just feels right.
chetnixandflill
What an amazing game. A true masterpiece.
ButIBuildAThousandBridges
That Cuba-esque level though...
chetnixandflill
Yeah, I hear you. Still though, quickly forgotten
mycleverusernameisthis
I’m 98% completed. Just gotta collect the ‘exotics’. I swear to god when I’m done, that guy is gonna take a lasso tour of Saint Denis.
draculaura
Omg that mission kicked my butt the first time- I learned to start hunting in chapt 2
Vakkeran
Sandy knees
GloriousPirateBeard
Those fucking turkeys are the bane of my existence. Cannot find one
BaldBandit
Is it a special kind? Those fuckers kept taking all the spawning slots for me when I was going after camp improvements.
theBirk
OK soooo. Bought it a few months ago. Beautiful landscapes etc., really. But the game is. So. Goddamn. Fucking. Slow. Everything takes 1/2
wiltsjunk
I got used to the looting pretty quickly. And once you're out of chapter one it picked up the pace, to me at least
theBirk
2/2 ages. The movement. The traveling. Even looting corpses or boxes. Nearly no GUI as well. So how do you guys like it so much?Teach me plz
Hyero
You just have to take it all in and let yourself get absorbed by it. It's a clunky mess for sure, but once you're into it you won't notice.
theBirk
Thanks guys, I'll give it another try then!
thadickenz
Hey, did you by chance give it another go? How did you feel about it, if so? Would be interested to hear a follow up to this.
nemilyk
You're not alone. I don't hate the game, but it's far from being in my 'favorites' for games.
numbonvalium
At the start "I want to play as John again." At the end "can we go back in time and cure TB, and throw Micah from a moving train?"
InspectorMonroe
You mean throw Micah *in front of* a moving train.
numbonvalium
Why not both?
numbonvalium
right into a pack of angry rabid animals?
Pbtibma
Only to bring him back to life so we can shoot him.
numbonvalium
With said time machine, I dont see why not.
DeadArcadian
Fun Fact: a few weeks ago I got drunk and wrote an rdr3 plot then thought it up again next time i was drunk and thought I was psychic
DargonBall
And you're not gonna share?
DeadArcadian
It had nothing to do with the first two games and I figured only I would like it :(
DeadArcadian
Unless other people like prohibition gang stories
commentsectiontrafficcop
Go on...
DeadArcadian
Gist is, WW1 vet gets back to the US and lives with his ambitious Bootlegger uncle, goes uphill then downhill
Blakbyrde
Yes
DeadArcadian
Oh, I wasn't sure how people would appreciate losing the cowboy aesthetic
detectivekagami
That sounds like fun! My mind went straight to LA Noire, just post WW1 instead of 2
DeadArcadian
Kinda yeah. still country crime but about bootlegging and gambling, more emphasis on discretion etc.
MathewCorbett
Gonna be honest i personnaly want to shoot dutch lol
LoudAngryJerk
play rdr1
ActuallyAnIdiot
During the standoff at the end, I actually did shoot Dutch. Immediately got blasted by Micah though, but it was worth it
LordTickleDucks
I did the same. At least 5 times in a row ! And then blasted Micah in his face during the Eagle Eye part.
ElvinNoodleSmuggler
Wait you can kill both of them!?
Worldbreaker12423
Theres a theory that dutch suffers a concussion in the tram robbery. Not saying dutch was great before, but thats when he goes off the rails
detectivekagami
Thank you! I remembered he'd hit his head at some point and got progressively more paranoid and angry. Micah manipulation didn't help.
Worldbreaker12423
Apparently wild personality shifts are a common symptom of certain types of concussion, and Dutch's personality severely shifted after that.
misterwappy
I tried. More than once.
theyar
Boy, do I have a game for you, then.
LoTRFanatic42
You don't get to show Dutch, though. He kills himself first.
LoTRFanatic42
Shoot* (oops)
theyar
Technically, you are correct.
DatDarthCaedus
If you replay the game, always pay attention to what he says. You'll notice he often starts with "I need" or "I want" before correcting 1/2
DatDarthCaedus
himself to "WE need/want". Also, if you open his chest at the end, you'll find equal to nearly $1.5 million in modern money in there. 2/3
DatDarthCaedus
The gang could've left at any point, no problem, but he wanted to stay and play rebel, fighting the gov with his manipulated followers...
MathewCorbett
Im close to the end i was avoifing beating the game to finish side missions...ill have yo finish it out noe...that devious bastard
mycleverusernameisthis
Hated Dutch more than Micah
Richter12x2
MIcah was worse, but Dutch was way more frustrating.
DrunkenMarineBiologist
At least Micah fully admits to being a horrible person instead of pretending to be a tragic hero
Boeskool
Then please stay out of the Netherlands, we're not into shooting like some other countries
Richter12x2
THEN TELL ME WHAT'S IN THE BITTERBALLEN
Richter12x2
IT'S JUST CREAM OF CHICKEN SOUP, ADMIT IT!
MathewCorbett
Its a game where you shoot things and dutch is a shitty leader who makes bad decisions
Boeskool
I know, perhaps I should have placed /s in my comment there haha
thekeyofe
I don't know why the gang didn't kick Dutch out a long time ago, and make Hosea the leader.
DatDarthCaedus
Dutch is a charismatic leader who has been manipulating them for years, and has actually been a GOOD leader while things were going well.
corbor4
because plot armor?
gastonlikegaston
Blind faith and obedience from years of being by him, probably successfully for a long time.
mazelt0vc0ckt4il
The events of the game are the gang at their worst. Before the infamous blackwater robbery, Dutch WAS a good leader so had a built up trust.
mazelt0vc0ckt4il
Also one of the issues that can come up with telling a story through a video game is that you can't control how players with play the game.
mazelt0vc0ckt4il
horrified of violence don't make sense so it can be hard to see dutches decline to madness.
mazelt0vc0ckt4il
They might play counter to what fits with the story. For example if players kill everyone they come across then cut scenes where they are
mazelt0vc0ckt4il
Deep down Dutch was always a selfish greedy prick, but even he wasn't aware that. The events of the game however brought those out in him.
detectivekagami
Didn't he get a concussion at some point and started acting even crazier?
mazelt0vc0ckt4il
I think that is the public looking for an explanation from random data. People thought Fred and Daphene were dating because they always went
MagnificentTurd
Arthur Morgan is one of the greatest and best written characters in the history of gaming.
dandacz
Arthur was great! But my #1 is still Mr. Trevor Philips ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
natedogcool
And voice-acted to perfection
draculaura
Lennyyyyyyyyy
ThatPAMTHorseGal
Agreed!
CreepyPete3
“Yerr alrigh boyah”
wiltsjunk
Hey Mister!
Awmadaze
Outta the damn way!
MASSIVESPACEMONKEY
*horse crashes*
LoTRFanatic42
Him, and Aloy from Horizon: Zero Dawn. To anyone who loves single player games and hasn't played it, do yourself a favour and play it.
chromed
My two favorite games ever. Right there. No question.
ThisAintASurfinMovie
Right up there with Max Payne.
detectivekagami
I loved Max Payne, all of the games. I don't have a single IRL friend who agrees with me D:
daverabbich
Well I agree with you
picklesue
You're gonna need new friends, friend.
ISpentTwoHoursTryingToThinkOfAName
I stopped playing shortly after Arthur gets diagnosed. I know what’s coming and I ain’t ready for it.
SepiaSkies
I started playing at the beginning of the pandemic, and I think it helped me brace for what was coming.
Hutchy01
Shooting the villain in the dick 12 times in revenge for what happened.
Stitchabarger
Fuck Micah in particular!
Krampus95360
I wasn't ready for it, but damn if it wasn't beautiful. I had a glass of scotch at 1 AM as i finished. I cried for a good while. I still do.
thekeyislost
Well now I know what else is missing from my dishonerable playthrough
Hutchy01
A soul.
Hutchy01
Well I got a twofer that got me reaching for the booze, I got up to that point at the same time we officially left the EU.
thekeyislost
You should finish it anyway! The whole story is about Arthur doing everything he can to get John and Abigail a better life.
Aarkenth
Finish the fight!
ThatPAMTHorseGal
Yeah, it’s been a while and I still haven’t been able to get over it.
mrincarnate
Agreed. I still won't play it because it hits me in the feels every damned time I see the logo pop onscreen.
Fyreworx
It's one of the best games i've ever played.
RyanAndTheQuestForWorldDomination
Honestly for me I was just pissed cause at that point I was like “before it ends I wanna catch every legendary fish and animal” but you cant
chromed
That does bug the shit out of me. And the most useful talismans you can't make until post-game.
TheflyPrince
You put on yer hat and finish that ride partner.
chromed
That's exactly where I took like a 2 month break before going back and finishing it. It's emotionally exhausting. But worth it.
delmain
Yeah I play games to feel better. If I wanted to be sad, I'd just look at the goddamned real world.
imaBme
I get where you're coming from, but why read a good book when you'll be sad it's over?
delmain
Its not the same. Feeling powerless to change something sad (like in RDR2 or politics) isn't the same as wishing there was more of something
imaBme
I got ya
XVUltima
Don't worry about it, TB was a slow killer. You got some time left.
ThatPAMTHorseGal
I think that’s the worst part... watching a beloved character slowly die.
TheWolfDare
A person's greatest moments are the ones he knows is numbered.
ThatPAMTHorseGal
They are, but it’s just sad to see Arthur go through it.
lonewolf9556
I knew he was gonna die, but it never made sense. After all it's supposed to be a prequel to RDR1
chromed
Arthur... Isn't in RDR1? Right? Am I crazy?
lonewolf9556
No, your right. I was confusing him with John Marston. Sorry.
hetriedtokillmewithaforklift
I so so wish I could go back to playing as Arthur. The other guy is okay, but dammit Arthur was the robber with a heart of gold.
trshalishaska0
Play the first Red Dead Redemption. John Marston is a good man who, like Arthur, fell into a world of chit
StillWatersAreFullOfMonsters
My biggest issue with John is his voice. Arthur is like rich honey, John is like glass in a blender.
trshalishaska0
John got his face half eaten by a wolf, of course his voice is going to be a bit gravely
ThatPAMTHorseGal
I didn’t know that this was my problem. Now that you’ve said it, I think this sums it up for me.
chromed
I know! I miss Arthur's horse talk more than anything else. I have a save file from mid game before it all goes to shit. I play that some.
SepiaSkies
Yer alright, boah.