This is complete nonsense. I worked for C&S Wholesale Grocers years ago. I worked as a manager at a facility that received and distributed watermelons (among other items). As part of my duties, I had to inspect incoming loads of watermelons. Resultingly, I've cut thousands of watermelons. There's no hard, fast rules. A melon can look great on the outside and be bland on the inside due to growing conditions.
This infographic, in addition to what seems to be wrong information, is badly constructed. You've got pairs that go "good, bad, good, bad, bad, good, good, bad".
Only once some years ago I managed to get the perfect watermelon, sweet and delicious. I know this because when I put it on the table after getting home it rolled off and shattered on the floor. The tiny pieces I tasted while cleaning up were heavenly.
I tried to use this (not this image) when picking one out earlier this week. Will be cutting it open tomorrow for a BBQ so I will likely not report back but I'll at least tell myself to. It had a spot and some webbing. Forget the color of the spot and too lazy to check
My father worked on a watermelon farm, I've been growing watermelon in my gardens for decades and buying multiple a week when they are in season from the stores.
Basically, just two checks, 1. push on it does it give easily? if it does it was stored poorly and its bad, if its hard/firm its good. 2. Dark green with a yellow spot and you are good, if its pale with a white spot its under ripe.
That's not guaranteed either. Excess water early in the grow cycle produces a melon that sounds good, but is bland as fuck. There are no guaranteed methods.
Dunno, every summer I cut open soooo many watermelons for work, and I always try a bite (cause how can you not?) and there really doesn’t seem to be rhyme or reason. but that’s just my experience.
None. Source: worked for a massive grocery wholesaler and part of my duties included inspecting incoming watermelon loads. I've sliced thousands of melons.
it's hard to read, especially the yellow text shape: "different varieties and growing conditions" spot color: "ripe / underripe" webbing: "it's a result of how the vines are on the melon" color: "dark=ripe; light=unripe; shine/dull=nothing"
in9119iwas
now do this for boobs
thevortexmaster
Funny. I was just at the store picking out a watermelon. I googled how to pick out watermelon and this was what came up
TheRoyalDong
walnutbreath
This is complete nonsense. I worked for C&S Wholesale Grocers years ago. I worked as a manager at a facility that received and distributed watermelons (among other items). As part of my duties, I had to inspect incoming loads of watermelons. Resultingly, I've cut thousands of watermelons. There's no hard, fast rules. A melon can look great on the outside and be bland on the inside due to growing conditions.
brainfreez3
You really think someone would do that? Spread false information online?
xxGreenShirTxx
Just pick any and put em right in the bin when watermelon belongs :)
naeddyr
This infographic, in addition to what seems to be wrong information, is badly constructed. You've got pairs that go "good, bad, good, bad, bad, good, good, bad".
quade
Give it the ole thump.
OhIfIMust
LordHosk
FlannelFlynn
Fighting the good fight
ItTookMeAGoodWhileToComeUpWithAUsername
Yeah more shitty misinformation on the FP. This community sucks more and more by each day that goes by. Any better alternatives to Imgur anywhere?
sorrybotsorry
This is what I come here for
danrrpalade
thank you
4vie
Watery watermelon tastes awful.
Skadoodlle
Only once some years ago I managed to get the perfect watermelon, sweet and delicious.
I know this because when I put it on the table after getting home it rolled off and shattered on the floor. The tiny pieces I tasted while cleaning up were heavenly.
nevergoingtogiveyouupnevergoingtoletyoudown
So I want a uniform dark dull webshot watermelon with an orange spot.
CrazyCatLad
I tried to use this (not this image) when picking one out earlier this week. Will be cutting it open tomorrow for a BBQ so I will likely not report back but I'll at least tell myself to. It had a spot and some webbing. Forget the color of the spot and too lazy to check
sevenfingerman
What should it sound like?
ChallengerDeep
Like the sound of a baby crying faintly.
ScarecrowSticks
You'll know because it has a certain slap sound to it
secondgoaround
Watermelon can’t talk or vocalize at all, so they’re pretty quiet.
Oblok
IMHO: Posts like these aim to help but they just increase anxiety in life. Odds are you've been perfectly happy about your choice until now.
binaryspike
What?? This would be spot on if it also included thumping it. If you feel bad about your current pick, well, now you know for next time.
shinagami091
Uniform and heavy with lots of webbing. Gotcha.
justareallylongemailaddress
I'm probably damaged, I don't like any fruits from the melon family. Hold the boob jokes, I enjoy those "melons" just fine.
vakler
Now I have to buy 8 fucking watermelons to see if this is true. Or double up on a couple options if possible. Dammit
binaryspike
It's true. Also, thump it. The deeper the sound the more ripe it is.
LordHosk
My father worked on a watermelon farm, I've been growing watermelon in my gardens for decades and buying multiple a week when they are in season from the stores.
vakler
Oh thank you now I don't have to be a watermelon lady from a math problem at the grocery store tomorrow!
LordHosk
Basically, just two checks,
1. push on it does it give easily? if it does it was stored poorly and its bad, if its hard/firm its good.
2. Dark green with a yellow spot and you are good, if its pale with a white spot its under ripe.
MatchaKitsune
skipweasel
I've always wondered how much of this is true.
ShimmerinStrider
I've stuck by it and so far it hasn't steered me wrong.
terajack2048
I’m a thumper , not hallow not thud, in between. Then I look for color and weight
Smileyguyx
this was shared before, and someone commented the only reliable way they've found is by tapping the melon and listening to the reverberations
walnutbreath
That's not guaranteed either. Excess water early in the grow cycle produces a melon that sounds good, but is bland as fuck. There are no guaranteed methods.
Lomish
I'm pretty sure close to none of it, aside from those all being watermelons
vindik8or
Ceci n'est pas une pastèque.
inphamous
The only one that seems to be true for me is roundness. All the others are variable.
Bixley
Possibly none of it, but I've had much greater success since using it. Probably ripeness and i once saw a sound one that contributed to good choices
CitizenPrime
It's all bullshit
CanIGetSomeExtraSalt
somewhere between 0-100%
feryooday
Dunno, every summer I cut open soooo many watermelons for work, and I always try a bite (cause how can you not?) and there really doesn’t seem to be rhyme or reason. but that’s just my experience.
feryooday
(we use watermelon puree in a few of our cocktails at my bar during summer)
golemwrath
Now you'll have to do a test on each of them! Down to the farmers market you go:)
SkeksiLady
Watermelons are like $7+
thatiswhyyoushoulddoityourself
@OP just being a shill for Big Farmer.
Syko73
or grow it yourself
walnutbreath
None. Source: worked for a massive grocery wholesaler and part of my duties included inspecting incoming watermelon loads. I've sliced thousands of melons.
Syko73
I know at least the on about round vs elongated is wrong. The shape is just dependent on the variety.
LordHosk
ByThePowerOfSCIENCE
it's hard to read, especially the yellow text
shape: "different varieties and growing conditions"
spot color: "ripe / underripe"
webbing: "it's a result of how the vines are on the melon"
color: "dark=ripe; light=unripe; shine/dull=nothing"
somnif
Even the spot color isn't always true, can vary a bit depending on soil conditions, weather, and variety.
Randomice
Conclusion: you will want a fat dull one, with a skin condition.
justherefortheconfession
Just like @op's mom
oldguyexlurker
And an orange, bald spot.
MelonDramatic
Present
Hurro
luxter7
Hexidimentional
oh its meeeee~
1BadPanda
Sounds like propaganda. I'll just take all of them to be sure I get the good ones.
Canofminus
Sounds like my Hebrew school.
Thresholdpush
Bandlith
Yes. 9 out 10 times I've been successful with it.
joeyecho101
That's why she married me, I guess
RedCamaro
Gold diggers take notes
ShimmerinStrider
That's more round than oblong
GenXHippie
LordHosk
That makes no difference, also the webbing makes no difference, thats just a result of vines on the rine as it grew.