Feb 17, 2018 3:18 AM
getupgetouttaheregone
135820
3146
97
carrotsonfire
How DARE you think about stuff in a movie!
IwentLookingForWhatTheBiggestIdiotHasToSayAndHereYouAre
I feel like the 2nd comment could apply to so many tumblr posts
animalluvr224
Standby. Asking friends at Pixar if this is real.
Browncoat101
I mean, it's true though. There aren't enough accommodations for lots of students. People can interpret things through their own experience.
bravotipo
Pseudo-intellectualism is the worst and usually indicates you are unable to grasp the context.
Astrius
Meanwhile, this movie on mushrooms was a blast. Damn 2 headed pigeon got me good
AgamemnonsMemes
"you wouldn't believe what my kid said today"
Nuggetti
I thought he just missed the shooting by being late.
kilroy4
Are you kidding? All our school system does is deal with the slow kids. Mentally disabled is a different story.
magoichi75
But we must go deeper!
Ilovepoopinglikealot
Someone on Tumbler correcting someone for making something needlessly deep and emotional. This has to be fake.
SuicidalThrillbillyturnedLunaticChillbilly
I was thinking the same thing
HanesForMen
Wow soo deeeep broooo
Kingpoopdik
Question. Can anyone who's gone back to college after 8+ years give me some insight. Just looking into it, I feel so far behind.
IvnWng
“Let me just tell you something...” why can’t a tumblr comment starts a sentence without sounding so fucking condescending all the time?
“Can we just talk about...” “Ok but no...” etc... JUST SAY WHAT YOU WANNA SAY, YOU’RE THE 1ST TO COMMENT WHO RU PRETENDING YOU’RE TALKING TO
housev1l
I don't *suppose* he knows how that word is *supposed* to be used.
dingofdong
Now I may have misunderstood, but is university not supposed to be an advanced education, unfortunately I'll suited to those who don't <
*ill suited... I swear autocorrect actively tries to create irony
> necessarily do too well in academic pursuits?
PinataKoala
Not everything is a god damn message, sometimes things are funny for the pure purpose of being funny
GabZonY
can't things be funny while simultaneously being slight social commentary tho?
NotTheSharpestSpoonInTheDrawer
They can, but that would need to be a bit deeper than "slugs are slow"
but all monsters are already anthropomorphised here, i wouldn't call it too far fetched that this could be commentary on the lack of >
>accommodations for special needs students in higher education while simultaneously being a stupid gag about how snails are slow
gakio12
Irreal
Wasn't Monopoly made as amcommentary about the evils of capitalism?
ImToxxiic
wellthisjustgotinteresting
But... I like the clever interpretation of symbolism here.
RayMC
So do I. Can't say I buy the guy's argument, but the number of people here who seem opposed to ANY interpretation whatsoever bothers me.
PickThePig
Same. Just because it wasn't intended doesn't mean you are not allowed to interpret it that way.
SO MUCH THIS. People need to learn this.
HtCtiwtchyk
it's not clever though. it's like, hey, what's a really retarded way to interpret this film? ooh, ooh i got one!
Why is it "retarded"?
Because it's pseudo-intellectualism. Hey man, what if Harry Potter was actually an allegory for the tribulations orphans have to go (1/2)
through? Nah, I think it's just a fantasy story man, but thanks for the really retarded interpretation. (2/2)
I mean, obviously it's not originally intended, but that doesn't mean it's not applicable.
BEANSBEANSBEANSBEANSBEANSBEANSBEANS
I know I'll get downvoted, but whether or not that was the message(probably wasnt) still doesn't change the fact that it's kind of true.
Is it? Source?
FutureFriedman
"I know I'll get downvoted" You will now. Quit the self-defeating, protective bullshit.
C18H27NO3
Have you been here for more than 3 minutes? Any actually unpopular opinion or statement DOES get mass downvoted by the Imgur hivemind.
Lancake
It's mostly random, sometimes a normal comment gets -100, sometimes an outrageous one gets +100. "I'll get downvoted if.." doesn't help tho
[deleted]
ImahumanIpromise
I'm confused. If those hands in previous posts are yours, they look really not black.
That there is an apparent inconsistency between your claim of being a black woman and posts you've made.
thtjuanguy
Okay cool I thought I was tripping.
CrazyMrowLady
I have never, in my entire life, had a straight white person call me out on my relationship. It has always been a few SJWs who make the 5/
Entire community look like shit. They offend us more than they ever could offend you guys. So next time you see one of those cunts, just 6/
GotHereThroughaWormhole
As a bi guy, I've been treated harshly for "not picking a side" and that I'm trying to "take everything". I'm not a fan of the LGBTQ groups
losboccacc
in general those communities draw a line to pick fights. we solved the issue of integration vs liberty in the 70s, placing the partitioning/
zamielvanweber
As a gay man I am sorry: that is just stupid BS that is just being wasteful instead of being the team we need to be.
Tassyr
I've run into this sorta. Though usually it's gay guys either telling me I'm gay or in denial, or that I'm straight and trying to be trendy.
StupidNoraGarbageface
Honestly though, what's wrong with trying to take everything in this short fucking life?
namiasdf
I like redheads with elven proportions. Does that make me racist, cause fuck me.
NickRivieraMD
*elfin
LupusLilium
But most of us probably won't fit that search, why would you want us to fuck you?
NiceGreenArrows
This is going to get downvotes but...it literally is. Discriminating based on race. It's still your choice and taste, and that's ok.
However, since you later say that you did it because of the hiispanic guys morals, not due to race, its not racist.
*IF you pick x guy, because you find x race more or less attractive...but she didn't.
OldGreggsBloodyMangina
Go back to Tumblr
I literally said the opposite of what tumblr would say. I think you failed to read and understand. It's ok, it was both expected and common.
Mangomancer
it's called Sexual Preference which is very different than racism.
Also, I used the word taste instead, because of character limits, but yep.
Discriminating means choosing based on. If their sexual preference includes a preferred race then...but as I said, thats ok.
preference, " greater liking for one alternative over another or others." meaning you like vanilla more than chocolate. or viceversa. >>
Racism is when you show prejudice over someone of a different race,and you believe your race is superior than others. they are not the same
KaruntheImmortal
The English class conundrum: Is the door red or is the writer showing his rage towards his dead wife?
Noob3rts
Isn't that a more philosophical question?
Irishda
Its not a conundrum. Usually there's just arguments about what the symbolism stands for. In most cases it does exist
derekhavlo
Is this an Ethan Frome reference?
BarretXIII
tumblr is like a dumb version of the stereotypical AP English teacher
Nalvor
Nah, it's just full of people with psychology degrees that want to show off.
just4thelolz
It never got that bad when we discussed literature in class. Guess I was lucky.
Studoku
It represents his desire to paint it black.
WesleySnipesAccountant
He saw the red door and he wants it painted black
wildatheart499
Give me a minute to raise Shakespeare from the dead
RydWolf
"Stanley walked through the *RED* door."
didntthinkofthat
I'm teaching English. The writer is literally describing the surroundings which may give you clues about the character. I.e. bright .....
pink curtains instead of red would give a different impression. If colour is used a lot or describes changing colours, may be an analogy.
And it usually is. Sad how so many (other) English teachers have managed to get these people to ignore these details instead of embrace them
My English teachers did the same thing, it felt like ripping apart literature rather than marveling in it. I'm trying to do it differently.
I'm glad! When people learn to appreciate literature, it resonates in any work of art they see later in life (movies, music, etc) ¹
It's really more important than people give it credit for. At least I think. ²
junepojohn
TheGreyKnightsBANNED
This. This is amazing.
TheAmazingPencil
At least post the whole thing
They are the same thing......
cheese131999
Those links are character for character identical.
The top panels were cut off from the first one, wasn't it?
StalinForTime
No.
valen00
What bugs me is saying how I interpret that is wrong
TheHaloFollower
Oh my god yes
ODSTsRule
What was the reasoning behind this? That makes no sense to me...
The thing is, your opinions are based off something. The trick is figuring out WHY you interpret it the way you do shoving that in the (1)
other person's face. (2)
GreaterDog
All the time in jr high, teacher teased me in front of class on how my interpretations were wrong. I was good at math and science and
therefore bad at lit, according to her. All while I won awards that year for creative writing contests. Enormously frustrating bullshit.
That's why I basically checked out in lit class. We had to independently end up with only the exact interpretation our teachers had.
It's not great but it does tend to get better when you move onto to a higher qualifications and look at context and new interpretations.
Which makes me wonder. HOW IS THIS AN EFFECTIVE TEACHING RESOURCE!!!!
Your teachers sucked. Either that, or you were terrible at backing up your interpretations & blamed it on him/her. Probably the 1st though.
Honestly I admit I wasn't the best essay writer, but I'd say it was about 90%/10% split on the teacher/me angle.
Dick75
I remember a teacher of mine fighting with me about her interpretation of the movie The Birds. Maybe she was right (1/2)
Or maybe the only reason the movie didn't end with the characters fighting a giant mother bird was because Hitchcock didn't have the budget!
The point is we don't know!
Felberin
Or.. He was just planning sequels but the production companies weren't up to this whole sequel fad yet.
dmex
This made me realise that we've kinda lost director commentaries when we moved from DVDs to streaming... I liked those.
PartyHatGladOS
Thats because their is a direct meaning behind it. The idea that everything is an "open interpretation" is inherently flawed.
To say it's inherently flawed is to question the entire basis of literary analysis.
Well, you have to realize there was an intended context first. Not just firing from the hip. Once you can establish that then go wild.
While, it is fine to interpret things the way you like, the author had his own reasons, often than not, none.
Assigning meaning where there is none is a dangerous road.
Always be mindful where the rabbit hole goes. Its perfectly normal to seek hidden meaning, but never safe to assume it is correct.
TheFoxCouncil
Sure, but the argument is that the author's intent is irrelevant. All that matters is the reader's interpretation.
Death of the author and all that.
If the meaning is not easily identified the author could have written it so that readers can bring their own interpretations.
carrotsonfire
How DARE you think about stuff in a movie!
IwentLookingForWhatTheBiggestIdiotHasToSayAndHereYouAre
I feel like the 2nd comment could apply to so many tumblr posts
animalluvr224
Standby. Asking friends at Pixar if this is real.
Browncoat101
I mean, it's true though. There aren't enough accommodations for lots of students. People can interpret things through their own experience.
bravotipo
Pseudo-intellectualism is the worst and usually indicates you are unable to grasp the context.
Astrius
Meanwhile, this movie on mushrooms was a blast. Damn 2 headed pigeon got me good
AgamemnonsMemes
"you wouldn't believe what my kid said today"
Nuggetti
I thought he just missed the shooting by being late.
kilroy4
Are you kidding? All our school system does is deal with the slow kids. Mentally disabled is a different story.
magoichi75
But we must go deeper!
Ilovepoopinglikealot
Someone on Tumbler correcting someone for making something needlessly deep and emotional. This has to be fake.
SuicidalThrillbillyturnedLunaticChillbilly
I was thinking the same thing
HanesForMen
Wow soo deeeep broooo
Kingpoopdik
Question. Can anyone who's gone back to college after 8+ years give me some insight. Just looking into it, I feel so far behind.
IvnWng
“Let me just tell you something...” why can’t a tumblr comment starts a sentence without sounding so fucking condescending all the time?
IvnWng
“Can we just talk about...” “Ok but no...” etc... JUST SAY WHAT YOU WANNA SAY, YOU’RE THE 1ST TO COMMENT WHO RU PRETENDING YOU’RE TALKING TO
housev1l
I don't *suppose* he knows how that word is *supposed* to be used.
dingofdong
Now I may have misunderstood, but is university not supposed to be an advanced education, unfortunately I'll suited to those who don't <
dingofdong
*ill suited... I swear autocorrect actively tries to create irony
dingofdong
> necessarily do too well in academic pursuits?
PinataKoala
Not everything is a god damn message, sometimes things are funny for the pure purpose of being funny
GabZonY
can't things be funny while simultaneously being slight social commentary tho?
NotTheSharpestSpoonInTheDrawer
They can, but that would need to be a bit deeper than "slugs are slow"
GabZonY
but all monsters are already anthropomorphised here, i wouldn't call it too far fetched that this could be commentary on the lack of >
GabZonY
>accommodations for special needs students in higher education while simultaneously being a stupid gag about how snails are slow
gakio12
Irreal
Wasn't Monopoly made as amcommentary about the evils of capitalism?
ImToxxiic
wellthisjustgotinteresting
But... I like the clever interpretation of symbolism here.
RayMC
So do I. Can't say I buy the guy's argument, but the number of people here who seem opposed to ANY interpretation whatsoever bothers me.
PickThePig
Same. Just because it wasn't intended doesn't mean you are not allowed to interpret it that way.
wellthisjustgotinteresting
SO MUCH THIS. People need to learn this.
HtCtiwtchyk
it's not clever though. it's like, hey, what's a really retarded way to interpret this film? ooh, ooh i got one!
wellthisjustgotinteresting
Why is it "retarded"?
HtCtiwtchyk
Because it's pseudo-intellectualism. Hey man, what if Harry Potter was actually an allegory for the tribulations orphans have to go (1/2)
HtCtiwtchyk
through? Nah, I think it's just a fantasy story man, but thanks for the really retarded interpretation. (2/2)
wellthisjustgotinteresting
I mean, obviously it's not originally intended, but that doesn't mean it's not applicable.
BEANSBEANSBEANSBEANSBEANSBEANSBEANS
I know I'll get downvoted, but whether or not that was the message(probably wasnt) still doesn't change the fact that it's kind of true.
NotTheSharpestSpoonInTheDrawer
Is it? Source?
FutureFriedman
"I know I'll get downvoted" You will now. Quit the self-defeating, protective bullshit.
C18H27NO3
Have you been here for more than 3 minutes? Any actually unpopular opinion or statement DOES get mass downvoted by the Imgur hivemind.
Lancake
It's mostly random, sometimes a normal comment gets -100, sometimes an outrageous one gets +100. "I'll get downvoted if.." doesn't help tho
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
ImahumanIpromise
I'm confused. If those hands in previous posts are yours, they look really not black.
[deleted]
[deleted]
ImahumanIpromise
That there is an apparent inconsistency between your claim of being a black woman and posts you've made.
thtjuanguy
Okay cool I thought I was tripping.
[deleted]
[deleted]
CrazyMrowLady
I have never, in my entire life, had a straight white person call me out on my relationship. It has always been a few SJWs who make the 5/
CrazyMrowLady
Entire community look like shit. They offend us more than they ever could offend you guys. So next time you see one of those cunts, just 6/
GotHereThroughaWormhole
As a bi guy, I've been treated harshly for "not picking a side" and that I'm trying to "take everything". I'm not a fan of the LGBTQ groups
losboccacc
in general those communities draw a line to pick fights. we solved the issue of integration vs liberty in the 70s, placing the partitioning/
zamielvanweber
As a gay man I am sorry: that is just stupid BS that is just being wasteful instead of being the team we need to be.
Tassyr
I've run into this sorta. Though usually it's gay guys either telling me I'm gay or in denial, or that I'm straight and trying to be trendy.
StupidNoraGarbageface
Honestly though, what's wrong with trying to take everything in this short fucking life?
namiasdf
I like redheads with elven proportions. Does that make me racist, cause fuck me.
NickRivieraMD
*elfin
LupusLilium
But most of us probably won't fit that search, why would you want us to fuck you?
NiceGreenArrows
This is going to get downvotes but...it literally is. Discriminating based on race. It's still your choice and taste, and that's ok.
NiceGreenArrows
However, since you later say that you did it because of the hiispanic guys morals, not due to race, its not racist.
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
NiceGreenArrows
*IF you pick x guy, because you find x race more or less attractive...but she didn't.
OldGreggsBloodyMangina
Go back to Tumblr
NiceGreenArrows
I literally said the opposite of what tumblr would say. I think you failed to read and understand. It's ok, it was both expected and common.
Mangomancer
it's called Sexual Preference which is very different than racism.
NiceGreenArrows
Also, I used the word taste instead, because of character limits, but yep.
NiceGreenArrows
Discriminating means choosing based on. If their sexual preference includes a preferred race then...but as I said, thats ok.
Mangomancer
preference, " greater liking for one alternative over another or others." meaning you like vanilla more than chocolate. or viceversa. >>
Mangomancer
Racism is when you show prejudice over someone of a different race,and you believe your race is superior than others. they are not the same
KaruntheImmortal
The English class conundrum: Is the door red or is the writer showing his rage towards his dead wife?
Noob3rts
Isn't that a more philosophical question?
Irishda
Its not a conundrum. Usually there's just arguments about what the symbolism stands for. In most cases it does exist
derekhavlo
Is this an Ethan Frome reference?
BarretXIII
tumblr is like a dumb version of the stereotypical AP English teacher
Nalvor
Nah, it's just full of people with psychology degrees that want to show off.
just4thelolz
It never got that bad when we discussed literature in class. Guess I was lucky.
Studoku
It represents his desire to paint it black.
WesleySnipesAccountant
He saw the red door and he wants it painted black
wildatheart499
Give me a minute to raise Shakespeare from the dead
RydWolf
"Stanley walked through the *RED* door."
didntthinkofthat
I'm teaching English. The writer is literally describing the surroundings which may give you clues about the character. I.e. bright .....
didntthinkofthat
pink curtains instead of red would give a different impression. If colour is used a lot or describes changing colours, may be an analogy.
RayMC
And it usually is. Sad how so many (other) English teachers have managed to get these people to ignore these details instead of embrace them
didntthinkofthat
My English teachers did the same thing, it felt like ripping apart literature rather than marveling in it. I'm trying to do it differently.
RayMC
I'm glad! When people learn to appreciate literature, it resonates in any work of art they see later in life (movies, music, etc) ¹
RayMC
It's really more important than people give it credit for. At least I think. ²
junepojohn
TheGreyKnightsBANNED
This. This is amazing.
TheAmazingPencil
At least post the whole thing
TheGreyKnightsBANNED
They are the same thing......
cheese131999
Those links are character for character identical.
TheAmazingPencil
The top panels were cut off from the first one, wasn't it?
StalinForTime
No.
valen00
What bugs me is saying how I interpret that is wrong
TheHaloFollower
Oh my god yes
ODSTsRule
What was the reasoning behind this? That makes no sense to me...
RayMC
The thing is, your opinions are based off something. The trick is figuring out WHY you interpret it the way you do shoving that in the (1)
RayMC
other person's face. (2)
GreaterDog
All the time in jr high, teacher teased me in front of class on how my interpretations were wrong. I was good at math and science and
GreaterDog
therefore bad at lit, according to her. All while I won awards that year for creative writing contests. Enormously frustrating bullshit.
Tassyr
That's why I basically checked out in lit class. We had to independently end up with only the exact interpretation our teachers had.
didntthinkofthat
It's not great but it does tend to get better when you move onto to a higher qualifications and look at context and new interpretations.
TheGreyKnightsBANNED
Which makes me wonder. HOW IS THIS AN EFFECTIVE TEACHING RESOURCE!!!!
RayMC
Your teachers sucked. Either that, or you were terrible at backing up your interpretations & blamed it on him/her. Probably the 1st though.
Tassyr
Honestly I admit I wasn't the best essay writer, but I'd say it was about 90%/10% split on the teacher/me angle.
Dick75
I remember a teacher of mine fighting with me about her interpretation of the movie The Birds. Maybe she was right (1/2)
Dick75
Or maybe the only reason the movie didn't end with the characters fighting a giant mother bird was because Hitchcock didn't have the budget!
Dick75
The point is we don't know!
Felberin
Or.. He was just planning sequels but the production companies weren't up to this whole sequel fad yet.
dmex
This made me realise that we've kinda lost director commentaries when we moved from DVDs to streaming... I liked those.
PartyHatGladOS
Thats because their is a direct meaning behind it. The idea that everything is an "open interpretation" is inherently flawed.
RayMC
To say it's inherently flawed is to question the entire basis of literary analysis.
PartyHatGladOS
Well, you have to realize there was an intended context first. Not just firing from the hip. Once you can establish that then go wild.
PartyHatGladOS
While, it is fine to interpret things the way you like, the author had his own reasons, often than not, none.
PartyHatGladOS
Assigning meaning where there is none is a dangerous road.
PartyHatGladOS
Always be mindful where the rabbit hole goes. Its perfectly normal to seek hidden meaning, but never safe to assume it is correct.
TheFoxCouncil
Sure, but the argument is that the author's intent is irrelevant. All that matters is the reader's interpretation.
TheFoxCouncil
Death of the author and all that.
didntthinkofthat
If the meaning is not easily identified the author could have written it so that readers can bring their own interpretations.