technicallycorrect
1430
26
8
Ugh. I knew Good & Plenty as "Licorice All Sorts". And they suck.
Jan 14, 2026 10:04 PM
technicallycorrect
1430
26
8
Ugh. I knew Good & Plenty as "Licorice All Sorts". And they suck.
dnsbubba
I'm with you on the "Good & Plenty." Horrible excuse for a candy.
YoursIsNoDisgrace
Good & Plenty could disappear forever and I would not miss it one bit.
gayvillian
Mounds. Right in the trash.
MrStealYourGiF
Don't be a wimp, pour the M&Ms, Mike and Ike, Raisinets, Skittles and Good and Plenty in a deep bowl and play Russian Roulette.... ... no but if all those were in my stash, depending on mood, either the good and plentys or york patty or maybe even reeses cups get eaten last (IDK I go off peanut butter for a week or two sometimes)
copperdomebodhi
I'd take the Good & Plenty over the Mounds any day.
sarahsaurroar
Twizzlers. They taste like .....plastic strawberry regret.
spiderjohn36
Agreed. With Good & Plenty's and Mike & Ike's tied for second.
rbudrick
Good n plenty. And why the fuck is it so hard to find good n fruity any more?
dunkum09
good & Plenty followed closely by York Peppermint Patty. after that I'm not sure, but discounting the ones I've never tried, i'd probably put Mike & Ikes, Starburst, and skittles at 3-5 (original versions only. starburst and skittles at least have alternates like tropical or berry that are far far superior to the original flavors)
DustingIsForFools
Almond Joy — coconut
TrilobiteSushi
If I was hungry, I could eat an entire walmart bag of all those except for Good & Plenty, Twizzlers, and Possibly Starburst (but I'd put a dent in those) so my least favorite is probably one of those three.
an0therthr0waway
RIP your pancreas
TrilobiteSushi
That's a rookie comment. :)
cjpoet
mounds, good n plenty, raisinets
StabbyMcMurder
Mounds. I think. Starbursts are way down there too. I love coconut but I hate the coconut in mounds, and I hate the chewiness of starbursts. It's purely a texture thing. I actually really like good and plenty.
StabbyMcMurder
Oh I also just realized there's almond joy as well so add that to the list. I'd be willing to eat any of the rest.
zanaria
I think I'd say Good & Plenty, not that I've ever had them... Oh wait, I see Raisinets, I hate raisins...
nimeton0
Good & Plenty. I wish they'd bring back Good & Fruity. Mike & Ike's just don't taste the same.
sometimesarobot
Good and Plenty/Mike and Ike
A couple others might be "eeehhhh" but otherwise it's a pretty solid selection
thebonesofmyancestors
Almond Joy and Mounds are not pleasant experiences for me.
LespritDeLescalier22
Toss up between sweetarts and rasinets
somerandomusernamebecauseididntlikemyoldone
Mounds followed immediately by almond joy, I have always found the texture of shredded coconut abhorent. I would rather eat absolutely nothing for a day than eat one mounds bar and eat whatever else I want that day, not an exaggeration.
GenXHippie
Good and Plenty can go straight to hell.
Stuffitwithbeans
Raisinets... Raisins are not candy
Sheepboop
spunoW
Eyeetsass
Fuck those Good n Plenty
FuckTammy
Good and Plenty = Mike and Ike’s for the worst. Hershey is a close second. After that, it’s mostly a toss up.
fformulaa
an0therthr0waway
crunchy choco PB bars from best to worst: 5th Avenue > Clark > Butterfinger before 10 years ago > Butterfinger now
fformulaa
Totally agree! After ferrero roche bought butterfinger and crunch, those are so much more tasty now!
an0therthr0waway
Gen X checking in. The worst of these is Milk Duds, because I like having teeth.
raitchison
My GenX ass would rate Milk Duds in the top 10 of that group.
an0therthr0waway
as a kid, I loved them. today... not so much :)
raitchison
3 Musketeers
technicallycorrect
Fun fact. Outside of North America, 3 Musketeers is known as a "Milky Way"
swedeonamoose
But the american 3 musketeers is more similar to Mars bars, Milky way dosnt have any toffe
an0therthr0waway
then what do they call what the US knows as Milky Way ?
CouldntCakeLess
Hershey’s from my experience. Shouldn’t be allowed to be called chocolate.
an0therthr0waway
Hershey is the Budweiser of chocolate. Its fans don't realize that much better things are available.
rotodisc
Bullshit. Sometimes you want a taco. But sometimes you want Taco Bell.
an0therthr0waway
jqubed
Hershey works really hard to make sure it stays that way. Brands that are good in other countries, Hershey’s gets a license to make them in the U.S. and makes them taste like their chocolate. If anyone only tries the U.S. version they’ll ask what the fuss is about.
an0therthr0waway
this.
swedeonamoose
Hershey's cuz it kinda taste like vomit or raisinets, since i absolutely hate raisins
isetprettygirlsonfire
Same
usernametakenisthestoryofmylife
I've never heard of Swedish fish, but it sounds like a contender.
Wuz314159
Swedish fish came out before gummi bears.
an0therthr0waway
imho they're fantastic. they're chewy but not snappy or gooey, and the original 'red' flavor is quite similar to VitaminWater XXX. They also have assorted flavors. They are a sibling candy of Sour Patch Kids but don't have that sugar coating.
CouldntCakeLess
From an European view: these are awesome!
iidky
Good and Plenty with Raisinets a close second.
arajad
I haven't tasted either of those. Of the ones I have tried, the Hershey bar is by far the worst.
keyblader1985
Did you just insult Raisinets?
iidky
They give me gas. It's not pretty.
Wuz314159
Saying "Raisinets taste like sadness" is a compliment compared to how they actually taste.
likuidlightning
Saying 'Raisinets taste like sadness' is an insult to sadness.
hamulusrex
Im one of those weirdos that like licorice flavored things. My wife got me some for xmas this last year.