slightlyalcoholicchef
194024
5353
180
Actual sad songs for sadness purposes
There's a post pretty high up on fp at the moment titled "sad songs for fellow fuckups". The list was pretty mediocre in my opinion, so I'm putting together my own and you can't stop me. No order of sadness, just in alphabetical order.
1. Ashley Monroe and Trent Dabbs- Gone
Ashley Monroe's voice is being used for the greater good in country music, not succumbing to the pop norms of today. She, along with Trent Dabbs, made a pretty sweet ep a few years back. This track brings down the mood by a lot.
https://youtu.be/07MPo7Ga-ZA
2. Brand New- Degausser
Most of brand new's discography is on the "I'm sad" end of the spectrum, but this one really hits home. "The devil and god are raging inside me", the album that this song comes from, is an emotional ride the whole way through. This song stands out on its own.
https://youtu.be/ZlktvwD-Ug8
3. Corey Smith- The Bottle
Corey Smith was a schoolteacher with a knack for songwriting. He used the money he saved from teaching to record his first two albums. In this portray of the effects of alcoholism on family, Smith goes with just guitar and piano to set a really bummer mood.
https://youtu.be/IieR4aVp2kA
4. Dawes- Now That It's Too Late, Maria
"All your favorite bands", in my opinion, is a damn near perfect album. The last track off of it sets the mood to chill to give it an ending that makes sure you're not too happy. Not the saddest, but still sad.
https://youtu.be/YMpmHIGxpBo
5. Death Cab for Cutie- What Sarah Said
"Plans" is one of the better known albums by death cab. This ender is sad the first couple of times if you really analyze the lyrics. It became a bit cheesy to me later on. Still fairly sad.
https://youtu.be/i_IpHfS6NT0
6. The Postal Service- This Place is a Prison
Another from the king of the emotional men Ben gibbard, this song will make you feel bad about yourself deep down. Best listened to in low light for full sadness effect. It's about drug addiction, so even if you don't do drugs, you'll feel sorry for accidentally taking that extra Benadryl when the instructions said not to.
https://youtu.be/NMgoQBHx12g
7. Gnarls Barkley- Who's Gonna Save My Soul
Wait, you mean these guys made songs other than "crazy"?!
The pure soul of this song mixed with the simple back beat creates this mellow mood that will for sure put you down. The live version is a bit different, but I'm adding it because cee-lo's voice is amazing.
https://youtu.be/GLbE6aHjF7g
8. Heyrocco!- Happy
These guys are one of my new favorite bands. Chock full of member berries, they bring out the essence of 90's whiny alternative pop. This song is one of the more bummer tunes off "high school movie soundtrack."
Bonus!- if you have an ex named Emily like I do, "First Song" will be the sadder song off the album. You'll see.
https://youtu.be/zdalPNMdM1A
9. Jamey Johnson- Cover Your Eyes
Sweet Jesus this has some emotion. It's the second song you hear off of his second album, so it goes from a nice, fun old honkey Tonk country mood to this cryfest. Even if you don't like country music, give it a try. The vocals and mixing make the mood damn near perfect.
https://youtu.be/mczbTQhDdUM
10. Jason Isbell- Elephant
After the Jamey Johnson song you have to lighten the mood up a little bit. Here's a song about cancer! Isbell is a downright amazing songwriter, so you can really see yourself in the story of the song here. It's something different from your normal cancer song and it's more folk than country. Give it a whirl.
https://youtu.be/LHJhyrrUTgc
11. JMSN- Alone
JMSN tends to change his style up with every album. This album was produced to be very ambient, and with this track and the following "do you remember the time", it will make you change your perspective on r&b. This song with the music video is a work of art. Magical, drug induced art.
https://youtu.be/6EH9xuMccy4
12. John Mayer- Edge of Desire
I believe this one was on the radio in some places, but I'm not too sure. Anyway, the melody and lyrics set the mood a bit differently than the normal Mayer panty dropper song. By the time you reach the guitar solo, you're hooked into this ride. Me being a guitar nerd, I love this because the tone is beautiful in setting this sad mood. Slow dancing in a burning room is pretty much the same review and should be checked out for sadness.
https://youtu.be/5GTbM5-ku-M
13. Lucero- The Only One
Lucero is a weird brand of country and southern rock that still plays on the sadder aspects of the country scene. There's multiple songs for that "my lady just left me so I'm gonna drink this 30 rack of pbr until I stop thinking about her" on their roster, but this one speaks to me personally. I don't know why. See for yourself.
https://youtu.be/SJ3S95KGlrM
14. Manchester Orchestra- I Can Barely Breathe
Manchester orchestra can go from sad and lonely to this powerhouse of music that's truly different from anything. This combines the two extremes usually found in the music and gives us this emotional ride all the way to the end. The live version isn't bad either.
https://youtu.be/mb5_miMF-p0
15. Margot and the Nuclear So & So's - A Light On a Hill
These guys are known for sad acoustic-ish songs, but I don't believe they can make anything more tear inducing than this. The mood just slows everything down and grabs you in the heart. The lyrics, vocal style and occasional piano heard in this track will pair great with a rainy day after your dog was ran over.
https://youtu.be/zYKWQXxeHZo
16. Modern Baseball- Pothole
This is another end track that just adds to the already sad mood. These days we have the kids that never grew out of their emo phase and just decided to make the music better. If you haven't heard anything from these guys, definitely check them out. It's everything your post high school angst desires.
https://youtu.be/W95u98wMlXo
17. My Morning Jacket- Dondante
I'm adding the storytellers version because it gives the backstory of how and why this song was written. The emotion in this by the end will send chills down your spine. It's not whiny, but it does a good job of portraying the mood of the singer Jim James as he sings about his lost friend. If you only listen to one thing on this list, make it this one.
https://youtu.be/dMbqlK5OY2I
18. The National- Vanderlyle Crybaby Geeks
The Nationals entire discography will destroy you like that ex that took your cat and burnt all of your moms vinyl records. Proceed with caution.
https://youtu.be/1a1UoljLWrY
18. Radiohead- All I Need
This down and depressing song adds to the mood of the already amazing "in rainbows" album. The deep bass in the melody brings out some melancholy feels attached to the kind of creepy lyrics. Probably what Scott Tenorman listens to often.
https://youtu.be/-6UH1Ls6ZvY
19. Ryan Adams- Oh My Sweet Carolina
Ryan Adams, or as the kids know him, "the guy that re-did the Taylor Swift album with actual instruments", knows how to bring down a mood. All of the lightly sung and softly played songs off of "Heartbreaker" tend to be a bit sad, but this one really takes the cake. The harmony really makes this one shine.
https://youtu.be/eMZYRvDvgT4
20. Third Eye Blind- God of Wine
I really just wanted to use this bad stock image. Third eye blind actually made a lot of really good songs other than semi charmed life. Slow motion is also kind of a ducked up song if you're into this one.
https://youtu.be/vz2tL6Xavhg
21. Youth Group- Skeleton Jar
The last song on the list comes from the post-Cure era and the start of popular emo stuff. 2005 was a weird time for all of us, but these guys seemed to be really sad about something. The melody is pretty neat though. Definitely check this over my chemical romance you emo fuck.
https://youtu.be/HnqRVCIEfdQ
Dog Tax. I'm sure he's sad In this pic.
Churbebun
Asleep by The Smiths is also pretty sad. And Behind the bars by Elliott Smith!
ashirian
+1 for the accurate description of The National discography
narwallaby
Daisy by Brand New is so depressing
BronzeLeaguePro
Blue October - Hate Me https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDxgSvJINlU
Blinkordeath182
The Devil and God are Raging Inside Me is one of the best albums ever
slinkydinky
How about Casimir Pulaski day with Sufjan Stevens?
Loser1Alter1Ego
+1 for Manchester Orchestra
neborno
I feel that there are better MO songs for Sadness. My Friend Marcus, I can Feel a Hot One, The River, Where Have You Been, The River...
Isi151e
Brand New brings me back to highschool. Went to see them live a couple times totally worth it
AnUnhingedFerrisWheelRollingTowardTheSea
saw them live last year, missed them when they were back last month they were incredible
georgetheboar
What about "Strange fruit" And "After Laughter (comes tears)"?
n0n53n53
Strange Fruit always gets me. You can feel the sadness down to your soul
projectarchangel
The drugs don't work by the Verve. Saddest song I know
LordCommanderTomSnow
No Elliott Smith?
JesusTittyFuckinChrist
Twilight, fuckkk
stewizbad
Everyday is exactly the same-NIN
n0n53n53
I believe I can see the future cause I repeat the same routine
spookyactionatadistance
Iron and Wine - The Trapeze Swinger. Please, remember me. Fondly. I heard from someone you're still pretty.
secretoaster
https://youtu.be/4zAThXFOy2c this song fucks me up for a week
HiggityHitler
.
maliciousGman
"Slow Motion" by Third-Eye Blind is incredibly fucked up.
Begotten
Background was way better. Doesn't really feel sad but the lyrics are.
TheMemesOfProduction
The Smiths - This night has opened my eyes. Always gets me
IAmAGentlemanAndAScholar
Poke - frightened rabbit.
iwouldratherbeoutside
No Children by The Mountain Goats
bananafoursale
I hope you die. I hope we both die.
MrtheOffender
Seriously, a "sad song list" without Don't take the girl, Landslide, or Last Kiss? that's just.... *tear*
atoyot
Ugh Landslide just ruins me.
NewZea1and
Hurt covered by Johnny Cash gets me. Disturbed's cover of Sound of Silence too
NationalistCanadianMooseWarrior
Disturbed did an AMAZING job with it, his voice is just incredible.
EndgameArchitecture
Jimmy Eat World, "Hear You Me"
WhattaYaLookingFor
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMTKb-pgxGI Warren Zevon - Keep Me In Your Heart He had a form of terminal lung cancer.
reid2048
Also Mohamed's radio and looking for the next best thing always get me
HiggityHitler
.
CouncilmanJeremyJamm
Zevon is an absolute treasure
Xeneth
I don't know about sad but Johnny Cash's cover of hurt is fairly somber and incredibly emotional
DirtyDeuce
The video leaves me in tears, guaranteed.
dirtehscandi
Oh boy @op you left out Whiskey Lullaby by Brad Paisley and Alison Krauss....
chuck1243
A family member of mine had just commited suicide when that song first became popular. We couldnt listen to the radio on the drive to texas1
chuck1243
for the funeral because it kept being played every half hour.
slowpy
Agreed! Saddest song ever!
Iceman0624
Came here to say I was surprised to not see that song
hellifiknowwhatsgoingon
I was also expecting whiskey lullaby
theoutlawedwoman
Same. I was about to comment it, but saw I was beat to it.
danigirl8807
He stopped loving her today. That song can make me cry no matter my mood
GingervitisIsContagious
Omg yes... Also Giddyup Go, while we're on old country.
Skylar102
Oh boy, have you heard the Jon Randall version of that song? https://youtu.be/ohSrY6DOA2I
bloodvisionsbloodvisions
Anything by Elliot Smith.
DirtyDeuce
Was about to reply with Needle in the Hay, but you beat me to it.
NeatBoa
Fuckin' love that song!
spookyactionatadistance
First time I made my ex listen to Elliot Smith she told me that this guy was depressed and would kill himself.
renegade0782
I was about to point out that he was missing. Either/Or and XO I still listen to today.
ThatsDangerous
Fuck, I just spent 10 minutes looking for a song titled "Anything" by Elliot Smith
Lucidalabbra
Needle in the Hay. Google that. It's amazing. No homo.
YeahFairiesWearBootsNala2011
"All around me are familiar faces, worn out places"
AttackPenguin666
This is Gary jules Mad world if you were looking for it
homeslicy
Better version in my opinion by Tears For Fears. Original also if I'm not mistaken
BrobiwanKenobro
Do you find it funny? Kind of sad, perhaps?
YeahFairiesWearBootsNala2011
These dreams in which I'm dying are my best dreams though, the best I've ever had
BrobiwanKenobro
The dreams in which im dying are the best ive ever had....... oh so relatable. Damn. The fuck is wrong with us...
DJKhaled
https://open.spotify.com/user/213qdecz7wgyunuphkgi53zuy/playlist/3NohFZoEdVA1VClJ2JvFsU spotify playlist for those interested
Hoe4GarlicBread
You saved me a helluva lot of YouTube tabs. Thank you. <3
spitfire
You are my hero.
ecuadorky
You the real MVP.
ecuadorky
You the real MVP.
Bentarmbenny
True love waits - Radiohead . A true downer of a song but it's excellent .
0Chey0
How to disappear completely and never be found- Radiohead.
VikingInOz
With you, from Ghost the musical
0Chey0
Sail to the moon- Radiohead
0Chey0
Pyramid song is one of my favorite songs.
aabe
go slowly. in rainbow double pack really has some downers, innit?
Ilikeyourbelt
Motion Picture soundtrack
Bentarmbenny
And daydreaming ! Fuck Radiohead have some sad songs .
Dynomitekills
Brand new for the win. Good call.
CheesusChrisp
Should have put Daisy. That song fucks me up
mikerhoener
So happy to see a fellow Brand New fan
NobodyLurksLikeGaston
Them being Martin Shkreli's favorite band put a sour taste in my mouth though
ifeltyourpoltergeistlovelikesavannahheat
My second favorite band! I saw them perform twice this year. Degausser is great but Limousine is a more gut wrenching song for me.
Jollyburger
Saw them in Tampa in July! They were AMAZING!
Dynomitekills
I just flew out to Vegas to see them perform. Then drove to Corpus Christi to see them again. Amazing band.
gopracticespittingoutteeth
If ur still in high school
brianthefly
Really dude. If you stop liking music and movies because you liked them in high school, youre gonna have a bad time.
BenWyattCalzoneKingandIceTownClown
im 24 years old and I still enjoy brand new saw them again this past summer
demuredanielle
in Chicago, by chance?
BenWyattCalzoneKingandIceTownClown
South of boston at the xfinity center
elsonico
Anyway, here's wonderwall
josephh92
.
TheAnswerWasAlwaysMoreLube
Almost all my playlists are downer songs, so I wont listen now, but I will favorite, because almost all my favorite songs are downer songs.
titimonkey
Bastard you put a smile on my face when I was planning to brood all day
elsonico
realmdweller
Wondermaul*
EdButterfield
This should have so many more upvotes
lcranston1930
Ryan adams did that one too, and it's amazing. Oasis even said it's better than the original.
WillowRosenberg
Always gonna upvote Ryan Adams. But you wanna hear a sad song by Ryan? Check out 'Dear John'.
lcranston1930
Hell yeah dude. If I am a stranger, dear chicago, wrecking ball and Kim too are pretty sad.
WillowRosenberg
Aw man, Dear Chicago kills me. His whole catalogue is full of songs that'll tear your heart out. Part of the reason I love his music so much
WillowRosenberg
The first time I heard him since 'Oh My Sweet Carolina' live, I couldn't even breathe.