Mar 4, 2020 9:45 AM
BrisbaneHorrorGal
87008
1766
83
taylorsassymylee1
This makes me sad...So sorry to all the plants I murdered ???
paulhollywood9
The "scream" is not caused by pain,its caused by vibration of bubbles in the stem to communicate to other plants when there is no water.
myUsernameWasAlreadyTakenAndIHaveAcceptedMyFate
Considering the lack of a nervous system, I'm gonna call bs on that
DrKonrad
ilikehornets
This is why I only eat animals I personally killed with a tire iron
aubuc
Thats why I only eat things that cast no shadow
TheDanWithNoName
7th level? Nice
SirBrendan
So we're clear, plants don't scream and only an asshole clickbaiter would frame it that way.
MaxandSlow
How to save the lives of the bacteria that I kill during breathing
ObsceneTentacularInsertions
guess I'll die
Dragondraikk
stop breathing, problem solved
Amazing solution.
opentangent
The nervous system is a thing, that's where the line is drawn
Targe0
The animal form of a nervous system.
Plants don't have a brain,pain receptors or nerves. Also they evolved with roots to stay in a spot.They however do talk to each other.
Also without plants being eaten,forget humans,no animal or fish will survive.
vauhtihirmu
That's just the kind of crazy thing Alex Jones would say. /s
Youhavinagiraffe
Rocks make a noise if you break them apart...
realskramz
more like vegans:
FormulatedVagabond
Yup
amop
The smell of fresh cut grass is a stress pheromone
Sircowdog1
The sound is caused by cavitation in the xylem, not by emotional response to distress or pain.
MyNameIsRichardCS54
Keep telling yourself that, vegan!
RussianHackersAreMyExcuseForEverything
Beet is murder.
SingleWhiteMonkey
I told my vegan girlfriend this and she said, "There's a big difference between a chicken and a carrot."
noctarn
I just know I couldn't kill and butcher a cow myself, could barely do it to a chicken. I can't pay someone to do what I find traumatic
TippyTheTripod
I like telling people that the smell of fresh cut grass is because it's screaming
You are not actually to far off with that, many plant comunicate with each other using chemical gas releases. So some scream with scents.
Felrian
No. Releasing gas is not equivocal to consious terror
From an animal perspective, plants are a different form of life and thus have slightly different rules.
madmorf
Lots of microorganisms in water. Mass murder. Just sayin’.
FarkasMacTavish
No, they release a chemical that some animals find malodorous, and makes them stop eating it.
iFreilicht
It's actually a sound they're emitting: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/507590v4.full Pretty cool, but a far cry from "screaming".
Still seems like a deterrent to me.
CyanideBreathMint
Wtf? That's old LRon Hubbard pseudo science from the 60's.
I thought so, but the study is from 2019: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/507590v4.full
This article is a preprint and has not been certified by peer review
It's pop science
'science'
Like I said...L Ron Hubbard bs.
slintbob
“I’m not vegan because I don’t like eating meat. I’m vegan because I fucking hate vegetables.” someone on Imgur that one time
Imalwaysready
ha. I remember getting that as a "tagline" on an e-mail in the late 80s. been around forever. Sigh. I miss e-mail taglines...
TheDino
One time? Like every post where veganism is brought up.
Really, I honestly saw it for the first time last week.
juicynibbler
Yeah, been around for awhile. You can still like that saying tho!
letstalkaboutSexism
Im vegan, even if that headline is correct, I don't care. Plants don't have sentience in any meaningful way
SuperPickle17
Neither do people.
Astaaroth
They don't have a central nervous system and with that no ability to feel anything.
Irejectyourrealityandsubstituteitwithmyown
Ah yes, as shown by sci fi author L. Ron Hubbard prior to creating scientology
Densteef
It's true tho https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-7773333/Plants-emit-ultrasonic-scream-stems-cut-water-short-supply.html
BenSnow97
daily mail and scientology, peak credibility right here
Check the study itself: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/507590v4.full
It's an ultrasonic sound, spun into the word scream to garner more readers.
Yeah that's quite annoying, it's very clickbaity in that way. But I think the basic results of the study are quite interesting.
Crowlands
To what end? Do the other plants go "Oh shit, better get away from whatever just injured Barry!"?
Pentacus
Iirc some plants will turn themselves bitter to discourage... predation(?) if they hear Barry screaming in pain.
NeynasGhost
Indeed! And also they will slow their growth so they have a reserve of energy etc to regrow if whatever got Barry takes a chunk out of them.
There's tea that is purposefully exposed to fungus/bugs because it will react by changing its makeup to repel them. Alters the taste. Also,
I had a biology teacher show us a lot of videos about studies that proved plants can identify close relatives -- trees supporting their own
saplings until they were tall enough to compete for sunlight, seedlings that grew slower in a pot with a sibling than an unrelated plant etc
I think one explained that the smell of fresh cut grass was a pheromone warning the other grass that something dangerous was there, so other
OhNoDontTouch
.
grass in range would slow its growth to shore up resources for regrowth if IT got bitten off, giving it a better chance to survive.
DrSharkbite
v
Zixtank
Good fucking lord. I could have lived a long, full and happy life without ever knowing the existence that is this fucking film...
Vulspyr
The eyes of the potato are eyes.
limonchiki
Honestly, when I watched that movie, it was WAY worse (in a good way) than I expected something called "sausage party" to be.
TheFastpaws
Well they did fuck in the end.
PixelSprite64
Chrisgopher
"Push me in, Carrot. I'll go to hell if it's suicide."
AgentOblivion676
Butt the baby carrots were cut and shaved from regular carrots...
ThePanda420
Heh butt
They don't remember. They're babies.
If I cut a person into fourths and shave it down will it become a baby?
Well, they'll probably cry a lot.
[deleted]
https://youtu.be/9VoNgLnjzVg
BobHubert
PyllyNalleMissionaries
DetroMex
Sausage party my guy. Fuckin weirdest movie
thedudeman519
Seriously. I saw the commercial and thought it weird enough. But the movie went way beyond what I expected
PorneliusHubertII
2 words: Food Orgy.
Cavin311
I cracked up at that part because I was imagining Seth Rogan storyboarding that scene with real groceries for the animators, made me lol.
Pretty sure that actually happened
FitzJustRight
Very much so, my friend walked out after the first 5 mins once he realized it’s not for 5 year olds
TheRealDeadBird
Oh yes, that definititely happened, pretty sure it happened a lot.
Ah bullshit internet science
Not quite, it seems pretty legit: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/507590v4.full But "scream" isn't really right, it's clicking.
Anything's a scream if you're cowardly enough.
"This article is a preprint and has not been certified by peer review"
One unpeer reviewed article doesn't lend legitimacy. Anything can be published if payed for.
CalumFace
You're denying the plants suffering and it shows
How so?
atomiccheesegod
Vegans don’t make sense to me, I understand not walking to harm animals, but why stop eating things like honey?
UnrustleYerJimmies
They dumb.
WChandler2
There's been research that bees are severely stressed ("suffer") when their honey is taken IIRC.
I've always found honey to be quite an odd one. I know several vegans who eat honey but not dairy products
So they can tell everyone they are even more special then other people
hereigokillingagain
Depends on the reason why your vegan - I've usually found there are three main reasons; Ethical, Health, or Environmental. For me it's a...
Mainly health and environmental as 80% of antibiotics in the US are used on livestock - it's a sure fire track to super immune strains....
Of disease/virus. But I still eat Honey and consider myself vegan as the world needs more bees. Higher demand for honey = more bees.
ikilledvestein
Commercial bees are basically an animal monoculture marginalising various species of wild bee. One of the factors driving colony collapse.
a ton mainstream vegan food is just processed oil/soy which they still cut down forests to plant
Yeah unfortunately there are foods that do that but like with anything you can just not buy them. Mainstream foods are vegetables, beans etc
Matsuuu
Most soy is used for meat industry as animal food.
Velosh
Life feeds on life one way or another, don't like it? Well...then die I guess.
papachabre
It's the ciiiircle of liiiiife!
Mechwarrior719
A wise dragon once said “Everyone wants to eat but nobody wants to be eaten”
RavenHellfire
This person........this person gets it.
thereisnoscotty
These are the cries.. of the carrots.
MyEssenceHasNoLabel
Damn you! Let the rabbits wear glasses!
yourelivingalloverme
“This... is... necessary...”
mrdoublejr1360
Till we move betwixt the air itself
SchleemRepurposer
Beat me to it you magnificent Tool.
zerokarma
retgarr
If you die then you’re just an enabler.
MeanWinchester
As my dear friend Percival Fredrickstein von Musel Klossowski de Rolo III said: "Life needs things to live"
hahonryjuu2
*interrupts you saying his name* You can just call him Percy
AdventTraveler
And yet the man was damn good at snuffing it out. Just caught up with C2, going back to C1 to rewatch.
pigoverthere
And I begged, "Angel of the Lord, what are these tortured screams?"
And the angel said unto me, "These are the cries of the carrots, the cries of the carrots!
You see, Reverend Maynard, tomorrow is harvest day and to them it is the holocaust."
And I sprang from my slumber drenched in sweat like the tears of one million terrified brothers and roared,
"Hear me now, I have seen the light! They have a consciousness, they have a life, they have a soul! Damn you!
BadgersNMushrooms
But then the bacteria in your bowels will die! You cannot die without harming other living organisms
vandan117
It’s the circle of life
True, but you'll also feed a variety of other things, it really doesn't matter what you do, something has to die.
CatchMeInside
" it doesn't matter what you do, something has to die." That's pretty metal
leodavinci1
That's the circle of life.
ILaughAndCryEveryDayFromU
The vegans maybe?
Aelok
I don't know any noisy vegans but honestly they're just trying to do good in theory, I don't understand the hate besides it's meme material.
Goldensands
Hating on self righteous stupidity is as justified and natural as it gets
parismaker
Nooooo! Don't die or else some life form might feed on you! Break the cycle and live infinitely just by absorbing light!
Cause that's worked out so well for plant life.
scroobiusgav
The sun is finite.
Correct, just move to another solar system ;-)
Yeah, but eventually the entire universe will experience heat death when all the stars die so...meh!
Don't be so pessimistic :D
I'd prefer to live long enough to see that.
Youre saying autotrophs are life though... do you see the irony here?
you don't think plants are alive?
No, i’m agreeing that they’re alive, but pointing out that they’re autotrophs. That means they don’t eat living things
NotWelcomehere
Venus fly trap is a plant...
Not an autotroph though is it?
So they don't get nutrients from the soil where bodies of living things have rotted?
Aaronbobaron
No, idiot. They eat Brawndo with electrolytes, it's what plants crave.
How did life start without life to eat at first? The elements that life was built from were already here.
GodzillaBoomingMarketOfDiabetes
I need sauce, i need to hear the scream if these plants
SteveTheEgg
National Geographic's documentary "The Secret Lives of Plants" is where I first heard it.
beneiththesurface
https://www.livescience.com/plants-squeal-when-stressed.html
ily*
Ily
PonyMadness
Guess you don't understand any big words yet. Give it time little buddy, you'll get there
Lol another retard
Hey what the fuck, you douche?
Haha great response. But don't take any of this personal
Gotcha
Lonewolfing
Look up ultrasonic.
How bout not being a complete dick out of nowhere.
Sorry, wrong person.
No worries, people will always be dicks though so don't let it get to ya! Imgur is notorious for dickish corrections
taylorsassymylee1
This makes me sad...So sorry to all the plants I murdered ???
paulhollywood9
The "scream" is not caused by pain,its caused by vibration of bubbles in the stem to communicate to other plants when there is no water.
myUsernameWasAlreadyTakenAndIHaveAcceptedMyFate
Considering the lack of a nervous system, I'm gonna call bs on that
DrKonrad
ilikehornets
This is why I only eat animals I personally killed with a tire iron
aubuc
Thats why I only eat things that cast no shadow
TheDanWithNoName
7th level? Nice
SirBrendan
So we're clear, plants don't scream and only an asshole clickbaiter would frame it that way.
MaxandSlow
How to save the lives of the bacteria that I kill during breathing
ObsceneTentacularInsertions
guess I'll die
Dragondraikk
stop breathing, problem solved
MaxandSlow
Amazing solution.
opentangent
The nervous system is a thing, that's where the line is drawn
Targe0
The animal form of a nervous system.
paulhollywood9
Plants don't have a brain,pain receptors or nerves. Also they evolved with roots to stay in a spot.They however do talk to each other.
paulhollywood9
Also without plants being eaten,forget humans,no animal or fish will survive.
vauhtihirmu
That's just the kind of crazy thing Alex Jones would say. /s
Youhavinagiraffe
Rocks make a noise if you break them apart...
realskramz
FormulatedVagabond
Yup
amop
The smell of fresh cut grass is a stress pheromone
Sircowdog1
The sound is caused by cavitation in the xylem, not by emotional response to distress or pain.
MyNameIsRichardCS54
Keep telling yourself that, vegan!
RussianHackersAreMyExcuseForEverything
Beet is murder.
SingleWhiteMonkey
I told my vegan girlfriend this and she said, "There's a big difference between a chicken and a carrot."
noctarn
I just know I couldn't kill and butcher a cow myself, could barely do it to a chicken. I can't pay someone to do what I find traumatic
TippyTheTripod
I like telling people that the smell of fresh cut grass is because it's screaming
Targe0
You are not actually to far off with that, many plant comunicate with each other using chemical gas releases. So some scream with scents.
Felrian
No. Releasing gas is not equivocal to consious terror
Targe0
From an animal perspective, plants are a different form of life and thus have slightly different rules.
madmorf
Lots of microorganisms in water. Mass murder. Just sayin’.
FarkasMacTavish
No, they release a chemical that some animals find malodorous, and makes them stop eating it.
iFreilicht
It's actually a sound they're emitting: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/507590v4.full Pretty cool, but a far cry from "screaming".
FarkasMacTavish
Still seems like a deterrent to me.
CyanideBreathMint
Wtf? That's old LRon Hubbard pseudo science from the 60's.
iFreilicht
I thought so, but the study is from 2019: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/507590v4.full
Felrian
This article is a preprint and has not been certified by peer review
Felrian
It's pop science
Felrian
'science'
CyanideBreathMint
Like I said...L Ron Hubbard bs.
slintbob
“I’m not vegan because I don’t like eating meat. I’m vegan because I fucking hate vegetables.” someone on Imgur that one time
Imalwaysready
ha. I remember getting that as a "tagline" on an e-mail in the late 80s. been around forever. Sigh. I miss e-mail taglines...
TheDino
One time? Like every post where veganism is brought up.
slintbob
Really, I honestly saw it for the first time last week.
juicynibbler
Yeah, been around for awhile. You can still like that saying tho!
letstalkaboutSexism
Im vegan, even if that headline is correct, I don't care. Plants don't have sentience in any meaningful way
SuperPickle17
Neither do people.
Astaaroth
They don't have a central nervous system and with that no ability to feel anything.
Irejectyourrealityandsubstituteitwithmyown
Ah yes, as shown by sci fi author L. Ron Hubbard prior to creating scientology
Densteef
It's true tho https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-7773333/Plants-emit-ultrasonic-scream-stems-cut-water-short-supply.html
BenSnow97
daily mail and scientology, peak credibility right here
iFreilicht
Check the study itself: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/507590v4.full
CyanideBreathMint
It's an ultrasonic sound, spun into the word scream to garner more readers.
iFreilicht
Yeah that's quite annoying, it's very clickbaity in that way. But I think the basic results of the study are quite interesting.
Crowlands
To what end? Do the other plants go "Oh shit, better get away from whatever just injured Barry!"?
Pentacus
Iirc some plants will turn themselves bitter to discourage... predation(?) if they hear Barry screaming in pain.
NeynasGhost
Indeed! And also they will slow their growth so they have a reserve of energy etc to regrow if whatever got Barry takes a chunk out of them.
NeynasGhost
There's tea that is purposefully exposed to fungus/bugs because it will react by changing its makeup to repel them. Alters the taste. Also,
NeynasGhost
I had a biology teacher show us a lot of videos about studies that proved plants can identify close relatives -- trees supporting their own
NeynasGhost
saplings until they were tall enough to compete for sunlight, seedlings that grew slower in a pot with a sibling than an unrelated plant etc
NeynasGhost
I think one explained that the smell of fresh cut grass was a pheromone warning the other grass that something dangerous was there, so other
OhNoDontTouch
.
NeynasGhost
grass in range would slow its growth to shore up resources for regrowth if IT got bitten off, giving it a better chance to survive.
DrSharkbite
Zixtank
Good fucking lord. I could have lived a long, full and happy life without ever knowing the existence that is this fucking film...
Vulspyr
The eyes of the potato are eyes.
limonchiki
Honestly, when I watched that movie, it was WAY worse (in a good way) than I expected something called "sausage party" to be.
TheFastpaws
Well they did fuck in the end.
PixelSprite64
Chrisgopher
"Push me in, Carrot. I'll go to hell if it's suicide."
AgentOblivion676
Butt the baby carrots were cut and shaved from regular carrots...
ThePanda420
Heh butt
Chrisgopher
They don't remember. They're babies.
AgentOblivion676
If I cut a person into fourths and shave it down will it become a baby?
Chrisgopher
Well, they'll probably cry a lot.
[deleted]
[deleted]
PixelSprite64
https://youtu.be/9VoNgLnjzVg
BobHubert
PyllyNalleMissionaries
DetroMex
Sausage party my guy. Fuckin weirdest movie
thedudeman519
Seriously. I saw the commercial and thought it weird enough. But the movie went way beyond what I expected
[deleted]
[deleted]
PorneliusHubertII
2 words: Food Orgy.
Cavin311
I cracked up at that part because I was imagining Seth Rogan storyboarding that scene with real groceries for the animators, made me lol.
DetroMex
Pretty sure that actually happened
FitzJustRight
Very much so, my friend walked out after the first 5 mins once he realized it’s not for 5 year olds
TheRealDeadBird
Oh yes, that definititely happened, pretty sure it happened a lot.
Felrian
Ah bullshit internet science
iFreilicht
Not quite, it seems pretty legit: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/507590v4.full But "scream" isn't really right, it's clicking.
vauhtihirmu
Anything's a scream if you're cowardly enough.
Felrian
"This article is a preprint and has not been certified by peer review"
Felrian
One unpeer reviewed article doesn't lend legitimacy. Anything can be published if payed for.
CalumFace
You're denying the plants suffering and it shows
Felrian
How so?
atomiccheesegod
Vegans don’t make sense to me, I understand not walking to harm animals, but why stop eating things like honey?
UnrustleYerJimmies
They dumb.
WChandler2
There's been research that bees are severely stressed ("suffer") when their honey is taken IIRC.
Youhavinagiraffe
I've always found honey to be quite an odd one. I know several vegans who eat honey but not dairy products
Densteef
So they can tell everyone they are even more special then other people
hereigokillingagain
Depends on the reason why your vegan - I've usually found there are three main reasons; Ethical, Health, or Environmental. For me it's a...
hereigokillingagain
Mainly health and environmental as 80% of antibiotics in the US are used on livestock - it's a sure fire track to super immune strains....
hereigokillingagain
Of disease/virus. But I still eat Honey and consider myself vegan as the world needs more bees. Higher demand for honey = more bees.
ikilledvestein
Commercial bees are basically an animal monoculture marginalising various species of wild bee. One of the factors driving colony collapse.
atomiccheesegod
a ton mainstream vegan food is just processed oil/soy which they still cut down forests to plant
hereigokillingagain
Yeah unfortunately there are foods that do that but like with anything you can just not buy them. Mainstream foods are vegetables, beans etc
Matsuuu
Most soy is used for meat industry as animal food.
Velosh
Life feeds on life one way or another, don't like it? Well...then die I guess.
papachabre
It's the ciiiircle of liiiiife!
Mechwarrior719
A wise dragon once said “Everyone wants to eat but nobody wants to be eaten”
RavenHellfire
This person........this person gets it.
thereisnoscotty
These are the cries.. of the carrots.
MyEssenceHasNoLabel
Damn you! Let the rabbits wear glasses!
yourelivingalloverme
“This... is... necessary...”
mrdoublejr1360
Till we move betwixt the air itself
SchleemRepurposer
Beat me to it you magnificent Tool.
zerokarma
retgarr
If you die then you’re just an enabler.
MeanWinchester
As my dear friend Percival Fredrickstein von Musel Klossowski de Rolo III said: "Life needs things to live"
hahonryjuu2
*interrupts you saying his name* You can just call him Percy
AdventTraveler
And yet the man was damn good at snuffing it out. Just caught up with C2, going back to C1 to rewatch.
pigoverthere
And I begged, "Angel of the Lord, what are these tortured screams?"
pigoverthere
And the angel said unto me, "These are the cries of the carrots, the cries of the carrots!
pigoverthere
You see, Reverend Maynard, tomorrow is harvest day and to them it is the holocaust."
pigoverthere
And I sprang from my slumber drenched in sweat like the tears of one million terrified brothers and roared,
pigoverthere
"Hear me now, I have seen the light! They have a consciousness, they have a life, they have a soul! Damn you!
BadgersNMushrooms
But then the bacteria in your bowels will die! You cannot die without harming other living organisms
vandan117
It’s the circle of life
Velosh
True, but you'll also feed a variety of other things, it really doesn't matter what you do, something has to die.
CatchMeInside
" it doesn't matter what you do, something has to die." That's pretty metal
leodavinci1
That's the circle of life.
ILaughAndCryEveryDayFromU
The vegans maybe?
Aelok
I don't know any noisy vegans but honestly they're just trying to do good in theory, I don't understand the hate besides it's meme material.
Goldensands
Hating on self righteous stupidity is as justified and natural as it gets
parismaker
Nooooo! Don't die or else some life form might feed on you! Break the cycle and live infinitely just by absorbing light!
leodavinci1
Cause that's worked out so well for plant life.
scroobiusgav
The sun is finite.
parismaker
Correct, just move to another solar system ;-)
Velosh
Yeah, but eventually the entire universe will experience heat death when all the stars die so...meh!
parismaker
Don't be so pessimistic :D
leodavinci1
I'd prefer to live long enough to see that.
amop
Youre saying autotrophs are life though... do you see the irony here?
Velosh
you don't think plants are alive?
amop
No, i’m agreeing that they’re alive, but pointing out that they’re autotrophs. That means they don’t eat living things
NotWelcomehere
Venus fly trap is a plant...
amop
Not an autotroph though is it?
Velosh
So they don't get nutrients from the soil where bodies of living things have rotted?
Aaronbobaron
No, idiot. They eat Brawndo with electrolytes, it's what plants crave.
amop
How did life start without life to eat at first? The elements that life was built from were already here.
GodzillaBoomingMarketOfDiabetes
I need sauce, i need to hear the scream if these plants
SteveTheEgg
National Geographic's documentary "The Secret Lives of Plants" is where I first heard it.
beneiththesurface
https://www.livescience.com/plants-squeal-when-stressed.html
GodzillaBoomingMarketOfDiabetes
ily*
GodzillaBoomingMarketOfDiabetes
Ily
PonyMadness
Guess you don't understand any big words yet. Give it time little buddy, you'll get there
Densteef
Lol another retard
GodzillaBoomingMarketOfDiabetes
Hey what the fuck, you douche?
ILaughAndCryEveryDayFromU
Haha great response. But don't take any of this personal
GodzillaBoomingMarketOfDiabetes
Gotcha
Lonewolfing
Look up ultrasonic.
GodzillaBoomingMarketOfDiabetes
How bout not being a complete dick out of nowhere.
GodzillaBoomingMarketOfDiabetes
Sorry, wrong person.
Lonewolfing
No worries, people will always be dicks though so don't let it get to ya! Imgur is notorious for dickish corrections