vcelloho
37356
1678
26
What the hell does reputation mean?
While getting reputation is neat and all it's frustrated me that I have no way of telling what a given score actually means (I suppose technically they mean nothing). So I wanted to find a way of ranking reputations.
Gathering Data with Scripting!
So what I needed to do was gather some data. So I wrote a quick Python script that crawls imgur and identifies unique users from the comments and gallery submissions. Don't worry I'm not the NSA. Using this script I identified ~25000 unique users within a short period of time. A second script looked up all of the reputation scores.
CDF of Imgur Reputations
If you've taken any probability and statistics you'll already know what this is. If not this plot shows for a particular reputation score the likelihood that you have a higher score than another random user. The labeled points show the minimum score for reaching a particular reputation level. For myself with a reputation of around 8000 there is about a 79% chance that I have a higher reputation than another random user (at least in the sample). A simpler way of thinking about it is that I have a higher reputation than 79% of the user base (in my sample)
Reputation Categories
This shows the percentage of users in various reputation categories. I found it funny that 3.74% of the sampled users have a negative reputation (Forever Alone). So if you're new here and have zero reputation you still have a higher score than nearly 4~ of the active user base.
A few key numbers
The highest reputation I found in my sample was over 2.1 million points! The lowest -199, you have to wonder what that user did.
You can look up your own reputation percentile
I've included a table that will let you estimate your reputation percentile. Just look for reputation scores just above and below your own score and this will tell you what percentile your reputation falls in.
nik282000
Greetings from the future! Awesome work!
IrrelevantButPlausibleConspiracyTheories
This is awesome, OP. You're a swell chap.
BreastInspector
I think I only have the time and wit to aspire to "trusted."
iPiano
Ooooh, stats porn...
mrfirebass
*stats science
polydactylcats
As someone who dislikes math related things, I didn't know I could feel this way about math! I fully support this and all future stats porn.
MrMcCookieMuffin
I'm into it
PaulRStafford
Within a day of joining I'm in the 14th percentile. That makes me feel special.
NateOfAmericans
Putting in a request for a fresh run at the data. Thank you!
ACarpenter
IMGUR SCIENCE!
sawuasfoiythl
4 percentile, and this makes me sad.
EatYourBacon
ObiWanShalomi
Haha shit man can't decide if funny or fkn scary
EatYourBacon
Dug this one up from the archives huh? :P
Foxygen
god this is good
TCTom
The little bit I understand of this is very interesting.
MyDarlingFeet
I'm curious what this data looks like mid-year 2017.
dragonofthesouth
Great post, gonna repost and give you credit one day
MaybelineforHikers
I've long held the belief that I'm at least 8% better than other people
QuackMcDuck
That belongs on the frontpage. +9000 for actual science
Resenate
this is great. Thanks for breaking it down and now 2nd google rank for "imgur points system"!! Good work op.
letthestalkingbegin
Also first result for "imgur reputation" now
ourari
Based on these numbers, I think I need to re-evaluate my life choices (rep: 61,597).
DevByTradeAndLove
Well this is more work than I would put in, so .. +1 very interesting read.
giraffrey
data and shit
JesusHorsedickChrist
This is going to be a bit skewed toward those with more points. You're more likely to get those users in your sample because 1/2
JesusHorsedickChrist
they post more. Actually, because of the way you've collected your sample, users who have never posted/commented can't even be counted. 2/2
mobiusstriptease
I'm below average. :(
1CorruptSociety
*in the pants
AssManProctologist
a year later and you're still below average lol
PhoenixQueenAzula
I made an account a year ago and did nothing with it. Now Adtwr like a week of sarcastic comments, I'm at 50%ish. Another week and I win.
mobiusstriptease
Whaaaat I have five whole thousand now. I'm like 72%!
Ant4N
Holy shit, you've got like 7000 points worth of just comments
mobiusstriptease
Shit. I've been figured out.
legofham
There are dozens of us... dozens!
KingOfAllMen
@OP run this again!
Thatsneatoburrito
i would totally read the fuck out of an updated version of this post!
ZiggySolo
Awww yeah. 69%
Fenrir1
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
narfwhals
the lowest reputation is far lower than 199
DetectivePikachu2
2 years ago and now we have @WarnerBros
Duskiewastaken
it isn't representative at all anyways, like the one user with two billions points
CorgisButtsDriveMeNuts
There was one user with really fat minus, can't remember the name now. Some pro hater.
Tamaaas
There are a few... newimgurian is this week's alli-hater
Katzatack
Edward
MikeyTheHero
macaroni
streunerkid
Fork
MikeyTheHero
Holy shit legend
vcelloho
Also -199
YouHadItComing
Wow congrats OP! Really really really amazing job there! I think this should go crazy viral, strange it didn't.
vcelloho
Agreed this was the lowest in my sample. I would like to expand my sample in the future.
Katemonster22
vcelloho
I want to rerun the script a lot will have changed but it will take me a bit of time to get the script running again. Sorry about that.
vcelloho
I'll let you know if I have an update.
Katemonster22
Thanks! I love this kind of analysis stuff.
cuddlescars
Is it possible that you maybe redo this? Analysis is over 5 years old now. It would be very interesting to see what changed!
cuddlescars
Especially in the division of Reputation Categories. Are more people in Glorious now, or is that always the most active (smaller) group?
RireMakar
THIS IS REALLY COOL. I'm saying it in caps so all you aren't TL;DR'n this shit. Read it! (I'm in the top 95 percentile, yay)
iamabotama
TL;DR: Worship me, I'm Glorious! ;)
RireMakar
The hell you replyin' to a 2 year old comment for
iamabotama
:) Don't judge me!
RireMakar
I'm judgin' the shit out of you yo
appollon819
Question, what happens if you run the script today? How accurate is this still.
Quigonjinnandjuice
Honestly, I'd love to know.
remembergoliad
I wonder how this information has changed in the last two years.
vcelloho
Well the number one ranking is wrong. I still haven't gotten around to fixing the old script. I have to check compatibility over the years.
Dayrest
You Should redo this. The data is over 3 years old now. It would be interesting to see what it is now
SingaporeanHoodian
You are over 5 years old so there
DrMichaelMcQueeferton
Now it’s six years old. Is there a more recent stats crunch available? I find this fascinating
velvetdream
How about now?
vcelloho
I'd love to update my code and redo this, but I really can't promise anything. Time is at more of premium now than when I was in grad school
LoganThePsychologist
I'm in grad school now and would love to run this analysis again.
Dayrest
Jesus.... my comment was two years ago lol. Also, what are you doing now that you have LESS time than in grad school?
ConvenientTruth
especially now after @dantee threatened to sue imgur
RwizCat
And Ndelray
GavinBertrand
Damn... he is hated by all of IMGUR now
whyisthatsofunny
And after parrotgate threw everything off.
ihopeidontoffendyou
What is parrotgate and how did it throw everything off?
whyisthatsofunny
Like dis: http://blog.imgur.com/2016/08/02/the-great-parrot-takeover-of-2016/
Suravik
"Neutral" it says...
ConvenientTruth
well it looks like they got rid of the forever alone category
ihopeidontoffendyou
I'll work on this! Can't promise results. This will be my first time doing such a thing
Quigonjinnandjuice
I feel like you're not doing this. I mean, you didn't promise, but still
MyFunFactsAreLies
.
Sensino
.
YouAreMyFetish
.
RenamedUser
I have it worked out for me to take over. I hope to have it done in a month (it's easy, I'm just busy) with about 200k unique usernames.
ihopeidontoffendyou
I'm getting close. You dotted me 11 days ago. That's 11 days of me knowing I can't let you down!
Itsnotreallyme
Bump
RenamedUser
I have it worked out for me to take over. I hope to have it done in a month (it's easy, I'm just busy) with about 200k unique usernames.
MyFunFactsAreLies
.
sexycutepopulartoboot
Woop
NateOfAmericans
.
authornotavailable
.
RenamedUser
I have it worked out for me to take over. I hope to have it done in a month (it's easy, I'm just busy) with about 200k unique usernames.